When the end credits surprisingly popped up my first thought was ‘is that it?’ The trailer that drew me to Cristian Mungiu’s Palme d’Or winner suggested this would be a dramatic legal thriller, with Romanian dad Mihai thudding his axe into his chopping block with a ‘you did your best, now I take over’ to his Norwegian wife, Lisbet, who we saw weeping as the Scandi authorities whisked their kids away because Mihai is a bible-thumping throwback who obviously beats his kids.
But it turns out Mihai doesn’t go on a rampage to get his kids, who aren’t running from him or the conservative religion they practice into the arms of Norway’s progressive Child Welfare Services, who turn out to be, well, arseholes.
So the sense of anticlimax soon gives way to head scratching. Who’s supposed to be good in this film? Well, Lisbet is obviously good. She loves her kids, helps the aged, saves an old man from drowning, and there isn’t any sense that she’s in any way being coerced into supporting her husband – she obviously loves him, though there is one scene where she whispers ‘I told you….’ to Mihai, because she knows the culture she was born into, and it isn’t his.
Their children, Elia & Emmanuel, are good too, with IQs and EQs up the wazoo – they’re strong characters, strong in their faith. And so that’s what the film primarily becomes, a conflict of faith & cultures, and it takes neither side. The camera gives nothing away. Keeping the frame wide and loose, Mungiu balances the good and bad in both worlds and asks you if it’s possible to choose.

The Romanian kids may not have mobiles, PS5s, or listen to modern music, but they’re in way better mental shape than Noora, the wrist-slitting headmaster’s daughter who has it all. Is Mihail right to mobilise the conservative Christian groups in his home country with inflammatory YouTube shorts? How does his belief in christian values balance against the baying mob he’s set on the school and court? What would you do if someone took your kids away and threatened to imprison you for your beliefs on the slimmest of pretexts?
To his credit, though, Mungiu sets out his stall early with Mihai. Later, he admits to police that he spanks his kids occasionally, but we know from the very first scene that it’s more than that. It’s an opener charged with tension. Lisbet is holding Elia & Emmanuel as Mihai stands alone by the window, still simmering. She tells them to go hug their father and when they slowly do he says something along the lines of ‘I only did it to show how you were wrong’. It’s the only time we see it even suggested, but here is a man who beats his teenage children whenever they need a course correction.

Those who should correct his course, the barely human Child Welfare Services, sadly seem to be a toxically smug self-perpetuating industry designed to remove immigrant children and place them with indigenous families to….do what? Re-align them with Norwegian values? Is indoctrination by the progressive left any better than indoctrination by conservative christianity? Who are they to define what best makes an adult? In terms of defining that adult, is the trauma of physical chastisement worse than the trauma of extricating children from their entire culture and essentially reprogramming them? Can these children please have an option that isn’t monstrous?
Mihai slams his fists on the window ledge as his children are taken. The headmaster slams his fist on the dining table when Noora refuses to listen to him. Both men a world away in outlook but loving their daughters and unable to change them. Then the film takes another turn by having those daughters fall in love with each other.
Above the politics and legal wrangling, that love literally floats. In one night scene we see Elia actually walk on water to Noora’s boat (“I’ll show you how to do it later”). In the final frame of the film we see Noora walk on water as she edges out into the fjord as Elia’s ferry pulls away. Their love has made them transcendent.
So the film hints at greater forces than the mono-cultures promoted by Romania and Norway. That it’s a love forbidden by the former is what impels Mihai to flee the latter with his family, even more than the threat of prison after their criminal trial. The power behind that love suggests that won’t make a difference. Noora has given Elia a phone she can track. They’ll find a way.
So, not at all anticlimactic then, in the end.
+++For those wanting some historical background on Norway’s Child Welfare Services, here’s a BBC documentary I cut eight years ago:
Our World: Norway’s Silent Scandal
As a result of that, questions were raised in the Norwegian Parliament and the law was changed, but it would seem not enough+++


Leave a Reply